How To Move Beyond “Fine”, When Conversations Get Stuck

"Connection isn't about asking, solving, or checking in. It's about being. It's the lightness in your voice, the warmth in your glance, the absence of expectation."

You pick your daughter up from school. She slides into the car, drops her bag. You smile and ask, "How was your day?" "Fine." "How was maths?" "Fine." And then—silence.

Every mother recognises this moment—the desire to connect, but the frustration when your words only make her retreat further.

This is the first of The 4 Coaching Fundamentals for the Teenage Years: Connect (Create safety before seeking information).

Why "Fine" Is All You Get

Connection always comes first. Before we coach, before we calm, before we create—we connect.

And connection isn't about words. It's about presence. That quiet signal that says: I see you. I hear you. You're safe with me.

When we start with a question—"How was your day?"—it lands in the head. But your daughter, after a long school day, is still in her heart. She's been managing emotions, friendships, work pressure, hormones.

When we go straight to logic, her brain interprets it as a demand, not care—and the wall goes up.

The Neuroscience

The teenage brain is wired to protect itself from judgment. If a question feels like pressure, the amygdala—the threat detector—fires. The rational brain goes offline.

Research on nervous system regulation shows our bodies constantly scan for safety through tone, expression, and energy. When your daughter feels seen without pressure, her body can move out of defence mode.

Sir John Whitmore, a pioneer of performance coaching, wrote: "The role of a coach is to create awareness and responsibility through trust and rapport."

Trust can't be expected—it's built through small moments of genuine presence.

How to Connect First

She climbs into the car. Instead of pressing with questions, pause. Take a slow breath. Notice her energy—tired, edgy, thoughtful?

Then try a simple connection cue.

You're not prying. You're inviting calm. That moment says: You don't have to perform. You're safe to just be you.

Once she feels that, she might stay a little longer in the conversation.

Your Practice This Week

Before any question, pause. Take one slow breath. Notice her state—calm, tense, anxious, distracted?

Then offer one simple cue of warmth—a kind remark, a shared chuckle, a small observation.

Only if she seems open, move to the question.

You'll know it's working not because she tells you everything, but because she stays in the conversation—just a little longer.

The Shift

Notice how often you rush to the question before creating connection. Try to begin from the heart instead.

You're sending a quiet message your daughter will feel: You are safe here. You don't have to earn my attention. I already see you.

That's the first fundamental—Connect.

Resources: Sir John Whitmore | Nervous system regulation research | Polyvagal Theory

Important: This podcast is for educational purposes only, not medical advice. Always consult qualified healthcare professionals. Full terms and conditions.

Your Feedback: If you have any questions or feedback you’d like to share, please get in touch. You can email me at: hello@coachingmotherhood.com or via the button below.

Share: If this episode resonated, please share it with another mother who might like to hear it.